Tournament: | Round: | Opponent: | Judge:
1NC K
Energy production is some banal shit – using the world as a source of energy to be ‘used’ reduces existence to self-interest and slides into nihilism, as if energy can be stockpiled, why not humans for the same end, to unlock use? This is the circularity of utility –fossil fuels are burnt to wage wars to get fossil fuels. Nuclear war doesn’t loom in the irrationality of the international arena but becomes feasible only when tendency to expend is papered over by ‘useful’ policy goals.
Stoekl 7 [Allan, Professor of French and Comparative Literature at Penn State University, Bataille’s Peak: Energy, Religion, and Postsustainability, 53-59](garreth)
“Bad duality,” as I crudely put it, is the indulgence … been transformed in and through death, have disappeared.
Rational state action is ridiculous – the construction of an orderly state is based on fascist desires and guarantees violence as energies break free from the banality of government. The fear of anarchic, “headless” society is not neutral but the deification of the monocephalic state to deny our own drives toward chaos.
Hamblet 5 [Wendy, ethics/philosophy, adelphi university, “The Manic Ecstasy of War”, Peace Review 17, 39-42]
Eli Sagan’s At the Dawn of Tyranny posits … ordered populations enslaved to reason and utility.
Risk management and calculation fails because of excess of IR → intervention
Harney & Martin 7 [Stefano, strategy, culture and society chair, queen mary, Randy, art and public policy chair, nyu, “Mode of Excess: Bataille, Criminality, and the War On Terror”, theory&event 10:2](garreth)
Still hot in pursuit of Bataille's horizon, we can now imagine … quickly becomes indifferent to its prize and impatient with itself.
Reject the aff
Stoekl 7 [Allan, Professor of French and Comparative Literature at Penn State University, Bataille’s Peak: Energy, Religion, and Postsustainability, 42-46](garreth)
And yet, if we think a bit more deeply … perhaps, the world’s (but not modernity’s) survival.
1NC Case
Predominance theory fails to explain the post-world war II era – history proves
Human Security Report Project 2011 Human Security Report Project is an independent research centre affiliated with Simon Fraser University (SFU) in Vancouver, Canada, Human Security Report 2009/2010: The Causes of Peace and the Shrinking Costs of War
http://hsrgroup.org/docs/Publications/HSR20092010/20092010HumanSecurityReport-Part1-CausesOfPeace.pdf
As with other realist claims… insurgents in national liberation wars.
Hegemony doesn’t solve global conflicts
Mearsheimer 2011 (John J., R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago, The National Interest, Imperial by Design, lexis)
One year later, Charles Krauthammer emphasized … have given way to a pronounced pessimism.
US leadership is unsustainable and ⇒ mass suffering, militarism and conflict
Boggs 2005 (Carl, Professor of Social Science at National University, Imperial Delusions p. x-xiii)
As, the United States moves to reshape the geopolitical terrain … the same global system it aspires to dominate.
Imperialism necessitates endless systems of war and global inequality
Foster research at the North South Institute 2003 John Imperial America and War, Monthly Review, May 28 http://www.monthlyreview.org/0503jbf.htm
At present, U.S. imperialism appears … the others—and hence the entire system.
Militarism ⇒ environmental destruction and extinction
Sanders professor of History of Ideas and English at Pitzer College 2009 Barry Online Excerpt from The Green Zone: The Environmental Costs of Militarism
http://www.revolutionbythebook.akpress.org/book-excerpt-from-the-green-zone-the-environmental-costs-of-militarism/
In a nation like ours, where military might trumps …—no easy task—it will continue to work its evil.
2NC K
We are already dead – the affirmative’s attempt to make us care about nuclear war and deprive life of risk makes life vacuous. Forget the bomb.
Baudrillard 88 [Jean, undissimulator, America, 40-42]
Everywhere survival has become a burning issue… a political fact of the utmost importance.
Allowing mechanized energy to run out, and accepting the uncertainty it entails, is good.
Stoekl 7 [Allan, Bataille’s Peak: Energy, Religion, and Postsustainability, 202-205](garreth)
And a number of authors recently have been … the movement of expenditure at its Varda-esque heart.38
Turns case, terrorism isn’t proximately caused but the underside of the aff’s globalization.
Baudrillard 1 [Jean, the dudest of bros, “The Spirit of Terrorism”, Le Monde 2 November]
It is almost they who did it, but we … it is the world itself which resists domination.
The drive for accumulation → increasing energy efficiency doesn’t “solve” scarcity but increases supply such that total energy usage rebounds to outweigh energy saved.
York et al 10 [John Bellamy Foster, editor of Monthly Review, professor of sociology at U of Oregon, Brett Clark, assistant professor of sociology at North Carolina State University, Richard York, associate professor of sociology at U of Oregon, co-editor of the journal Organization & Environment, The Ecological Rift, 177-179]
This led to the resurrection, at the end of the 1970s … “central materials” or “staple products” – are concerned.
Standing reserve is probably bad
Ziarek 12
(Krzysztof, Professor of Comparative Literature at SUNY-Buffalo, “The Global Unworld: A Meditative Manifesto”, Impasses of the Post-Global: Theory in the Era of Climate Change, Vol. 2/, [Alcibiades and Lenny])
At issue, as I suggested earlier, is where to begin… open for deciding. The crisis of (un)worlding.