Campbell-Lee Neg

FRAMEWORK:

The traditional debate framework is problematic and exclusionary.

1. Policymaking is bad.
   a) policy focus kills politics.
   b) state bad
   2. Policy Debate is bad.
   a) line by line bad
   b) exclusionary forms of argument bad
   c) role-playing bad
   3. Limits are bad.
   4. Ground is bad.
   5. Predictability is bad.
   6. Fairness is bad.

We read evidence from Dr. Shanara Reid-Brinkley, 2008; Spanos, William Spanos in Joe Millers’ book Cross-ex (pg. 467) speaks about this as well;  Shaw 04 (Katharine, Associate Professor of Urban Studies at Ohio State Using Feminist Critical Policy Analysis in the Realm of Higher Education: The Case of Welfare Reform as Gendered Educational Policy Source: The Journal of Higher Education, Vol. 75, No. 1, Special Issue: Questions of Research and Methodology, (Jan. - Feb., 2004), pp. 56-79; Delgado, Law Prof at U. of Colorado, 1992 [Richard, “Shadowboxing: An Essay On Power,” In Cornell Law Review, May]; Hill, Shelton 97, Former Debate coach at Biola University, “African American Students’ Motivation to Participate in Intercollegiate Debate, in the Southern Journal of Forensics 2 (Fall, 1997) 202-235; Giroux 08 , a professor in English and Cultural Studies at McMaster University ,Henry Giroux,: Rethinking the Promise of Critical Education Under an Obama Regime Tuesday 02 December 2008, Chronis; and Kincheloe, 1999, The Struggle to Define and Reinvent Whiteness: A Pedagogical Analysis, Joe L. Kincheloe Source: College Literature 26 (Fall 1999): 162- .

NDT Round 2: Neg vs CSUF MS

Strategy was about how their performance re-entrenches whiteness

They read the Reid-Brinkley evidence Spanos evidence. 1NC included some arguments by wilderson

Many examples they brought up was the exclusion of the black mother who has to perform both gender roles.

Also read a part of MLK's letter from a birmingham jail

Negative strategy focused on "proving that the aff is a bad idea

NDT Round 4: Neg vs WGA DF

Similar arguments about the aff propping up the academic structure it criticizes.

No new cards were read.

NDT Round 7: Neg vs Michigan AP - Wind Aesthetics Aff

Comfort zone of whiteness maintains that racism doesn’t exist anymore and is therefore no longer part of the topic of polite conversation. This is a new mode of white supremacy. 
Brimmer 05 ~[ Allison brimmer, "Investigating Affective Dimensions of Whitness in the Cultural Studies Writing Classroom: Towards a Critical, Feminist, Anti-Racist Pedagogy." A dissertation submitted  at the University of South Florida. ~]
The Culture of politeness: A major facet of whitness is…. Non-white other is marked negatively. 

Politics of wind turbines leads to whiteness (about comfort zone)
Brimmer 05 ~[ Allison brimmer, "Investigating Affective Dimensions of Whitness in the Cultural Studies Writing Classroom: Towards a Critical, Feminist, Anti-Racist Pedagogy." A dissertation submitted at the University of South Florida. ~]
In hyper-capitalist culture, education has no doubt…reality of inequality and our part in it

Whiteness -> social location – case turn to the aff
Flagg 05 ~[Barbara J. Flagg "Whiteness as  Metaprivelege." Racism.org: Race, Racism and The Law. Barbara J. Flag, Foreword: Whiteness as Metaprivelege, 18Washinton University Journal of Law and Policy 1-11(2005). http://racism.org/index.php?option=com_content%26view=article%26id=398:whiteness16a%26catid=69%26itemid=165~~]
Whiteness is a social location of power, privilege….defense in the maintenance of White supremacy. 

AT: PERM 
Frank Wilderson 2009 ~[ Red White and Black: Cinema and The Structure of US antagonisms, Chapter one~]
The moment in Western history when the….. more norecuperable and all the more isolated. 

Aesthetics – use traditional styles and challenge dominative order of debate
X Dr. Shanara 2008
Shanara Rose Reid-Brinkley
Significant for this project is the importance…… are limitations on what we can be.